Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
The DU Lounge
In reply to the discussion: Had a blood test for dementia today... [View all]NNadir
(36,198 posts)26. I discussed this very modern test elsewhere on this site, asking others, (and myself) if they would take it.
There's likely a test. Would you really want to know the result?
I wrote it in the Science forum.
This surprising find came in on my news feed. Just a few years ago, there was no biomarker; now apparently there are five
I am currently reading Charles Piller's Doctored, Fraud, Arrogance and Tragedy in the Quest to Cure Alzheimer's.
I am peripherally interested in the science of Alzheimer's, having supported teams working in the area.
Piller does quite a nice job at addressing "preventive treatment" of dubious value and high risk.
According to the book, and I'll need to verify this in the literature if I have time, there are people who test positive for tau oligomers who don't get dementia. I know of whole families who are positive for the APOE2 gene where Alzheimer's is unknown. People are looking into the genome of these families to see what's going on. It's rare enough to have not been known, but a chance discovery showed the case to exist.
As for the disease itself, and worrying about getting it, and ruining the surprise by finding out...
I wouldn't want to be tempted to take take test, and I won't do so. There's no reason to do so. I recognize I'm in decline, but that's the fun of growing old. The alternative was dying young. I have noticed some changes to my memory, particularly for names, and certain technical terms and concepts. The other day, I couldn't remember that neutron absorption in 138Ba results in the transmutation to lanthanum - the word "lanthanum" escaped me - but while I've always had a working knowledge of all the stable s, p, and d elements, I've sometimes stumbled, even when young, with the lanthanides. I can live without the word "lanthanum" on the tip of my tongue. Reciting the periodic table was always a cheap parlor trick anyway.
One will find out one's future by living it, maybe at the risk to not be cognizant enough to know it, in short order. What's the use of predicting the future? To me, mortality strikes me as a beautiful thing, as life is more precious in its presence.
As long as I know I love my wife, I'm OK and life, for whatever it is, is worth living.
I wrote it in the Science forum.
This surprising find came in on my news feed. Just a few years ago, there was no biomarker; now apparently there are five
I am currently reading Charles Piller's Doctored, Fraud, Arrogance and Tragedy in the Quest to Cure Alzheimer's.
I am peripherally interested in the science of Alzheimer's, having supported teams working in the area.
Piller does quite a nice job at addressing "preventive treatment" of dubious value and high risk.
According to the book, and I'll need to verify this in the literature if I have time, there are people who test positive for tau oligomers who don't get dementia. I know of whole families who are positive for the APOE2 gene where Alzheimer's is unknown. People are looking into the genome of these families to see what's going on. It's rare enough to have not been known, but a chance discovery showed the case to exist.
As for the disease itself, and worrying about getting it, and ruining the surprise by finding out...
I wouldn't want to be tempted to take take test, and I won't do so. There's no reason to do so. I recognize I'm in decline, but that's the fun of growing old. The alternative was dying young. I have noticed some changes to my memory, particularly for names, and certain technical terms and concepts. The other day, I couldn't remember that neutron absorption in 138Ba results in the transmutation to lanthanum - the word "lanthanum" escaped me - but while I've always had a working knowledge of all the stable s, p, and d elements, I've sometimes stumbled, even when young, with the lanthanides. I can live without the word "lanthanum" on the tip of my tongue. Reciting the periodic table was always a cheap parlor trick anyway.
One will find out one's future by living it, maybe at the risk to not be cognizant enough to know it, in short order. What's the use of predicting the future? To me, mortality strikes me as a beautiful thing, as life is more precious in its presence.
As long as I know I love my wife, I'm OK and life, for whatever it is, is worth living.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
62 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations

No, I haven't received the test results yet. I just saw it written on the order as reason for test.
CTyankee
Jun 13
#2
Thank you for being open with this. We all need to confront it - for ourselves and others around us.
erronis
Jun 13
#3
My diagnosis, you write too well to be at high risk. But might check with my doc.
Silent Type
Jun 13
#4
Well, if it is dementia, I am in the early stages and writing is probably a great thing for my mind.
CTyankee
Jun 13
#5
I don''t know. I just saw it written in the box on the form. I'll ask next time I call the doc's office or when I get
CTyankee
Jun 14
#37
you sound pretty easy going; i'd be really pissed off if they were testing me for something and didn't tell me or
orleans
Jun 13
#10
No, I had called his office a left a message about my memory concerns. I'm OK with how he handlled it.
CTyankee
Jun 14
#45
My mother told me that my sister bought some memory pills but kept forgetting to take them. Chuckling as she told it.
Norrrm
Jun 13
#16
I have one of those little boxes with compartments of days Morning Noon Evening Night and hubby helps by arranging the
CTyankee
Jun 14
#46
Please remember that even the most accurate tests can give false positives. Don't automatically
highplainsdem
Jun 13
#22
My wife and I went to a seminar about dementia since her parents and my father and stepmother are developing
turbinetree
Jun 13
#25
I discussed this very modern test elsewhere on this site, asking others, (and myself) if they would take it.
NNadir
Jun 13
#26
I hope you get very good results. My husband mentioned to the Primary Care MD, that he was having with his memory. Now
debm55
Jun 14
#44
Forntunately, I spend a lot of my days in art history, which I started to do about 15 years ago.
CTyankee
Jun 15
#57
With the internet SO much is possible. Just pick an artist you like and Google does its thing!
CTyankee
Jun 15
#59
Most of Degas' ballet works were painted in the Opera Garnier in Paris which you can visit today.
CTyankee
Jun 15
#61